Conceptualizing legitimacy as a thing an asset or characteristic to be gained, increased and lost clearly emphasizes some attributes of a phenomenon at the. Moral right to rule locke and consent social contrast theory we consent to be governed. This account of constitutional legitimacy does not assume any particular theory of justice, but rather is intermediate between the concept of justice and the concept of legal validity. The concept of legitimacy and international law by chris. The definition includes the subjects, objects and subtypes of legitimacy. Health care and the concept of legitimacy sciencedirect. Just as within largescale languages, such as english and spanish, words are defined relative to each. The aim of the paper is to deeply analyze a concept of legitimacy. A first sense of authority is theoretical authority or expertise. Legitimacy definition of legitimacy by merriamwebster.
Before looking at the legal concept of legitimacy, the following section will provide a short overview of the prevaling theories operating in the areas of sociology and political science. Friedrich, who states that the question of legitimacy is the question of fact. Definition of legitimacy the word legitimacy is coined from the latin word legitimus which means according to law. The concept of legitimacy in international law by daniel. Today we understand the concept of legitimacy primarily through the exercise. Power, authority and legitimacy are seen as an integral part of human society for the simple reason that these are the defining features of a social being with social and political institutions and hierarchies. For these reasons, this paper adopts legitimacy theory as the theoretical perspective for the purpose of explaining variations in csr within the afbi. The meaning and measure of state legitimacy wiley online library.
The significance of the nation state is that, once consolidated around a particular. Hermann perhaps the central problem of legal and political philosophy is the need to establish a basis for the claim of legitimacy for the rule of law. Wps 1220 the concept of legitimacy and international law by. Pdf the concept of legitimacy in international law dan. The normative concept of political legitimacy is often seen as related to the justification of. The first meaning refers to political philosophy and deals with questions such as. First of all, the people who are asked to obey authority have to feel like they have a voice that if they speak up, they will be heard. Legitimacy is a value whereby something or someone is recognized and accepted as right and proper. In political science, legitimacy usually is understood as the popular acceptance and recognition by the public of the authority of a governing regime, whereby authority has political power through consent and mutual understandings, not coercion. In the african context, traditional legitimacy is often associated with the wisdom of ancestral time. Legitimacy is a key concept of any effort to theorize how governance works, contributing both to the effectiveness and to the normative evaluation of the interactive processes through which. Perhaps the central problem of legal and political philosophy is the need. Legitimacy theory is derived from the concept of organisational legitimacy, which has been.
The problem of legitimacy, which is central in politics, is not the exclu. Yet the concept of legitimacy, mercurial as it is, has remained underscrutinised, leading to confusion and misuse. This article presents a quantitative measurement of the political legitimacy of states in the late 1990s and early 2000s for 72 states containing 5. Concept of power, hegemony, ideology and legitimacy since ancient time, social theorists tried to define the queries that people who lack economic power consent to hierarchies of social and political power. First, the concept of state legitimacy is defined and justified. Concept of power, hegemony, ideology and legitimacy. Max weber is perhaps the first modern thinker who seriously thought about the concept of legitimacy. Wps 1220 the concept of legitimacy and international. Essay on legitimacy and democracy patricia kaplanova faculty of organisation studies novo mesto, ulica talcev 3, 8000 novo mesto, slovenia pata. This raises the question how the concept of legitimacy may. The paper analyzes the relationship of legitimacy to legality and to selfinterest. Max weber and the concept of legitimacy in contemporary jurisprudence donald h.
This chapter discusses corporate social responsibility, corporate governance, and corporate citizenship in relation to business legitimacy as a basic concept in the philosophy of management. Political acceptance as an alternative or complement to political legitimacy. Instead of speaking of two different concepts of legitimacy, it is more accurate to say that there is an empirical and a normative perspective on the same concept. Pdf the function of political institutions and the concept. Results for 72 countries bruce gilley princeton university, new jersey, usa abstract. Political legitimacy and democracy the stability and functioning of any kind of political regimeincluding democratic or representative onesrelies on the combination of the capacity of rulers and government officials to use coercion and the development of political legitimacy. Political legitimacy stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Jul 21, 2014 this is called the principle of legitimacy, and legitimacy is based on three things. Legitimacy as a concept is a kind of metadefinition that seeks to encompass as many of the different conceptions for legitimacy as possible. In political science, legitimacy is the right and acceptance of an authority, usually a governing. In the united states, for example, congressional districts are drawn every ten years as lines on a map. Webers understanding of legitimacy rests on shared values, such as tradition and rationallegality.
Links to power and authority by transforming the former into the latter turns naked power into authority. Rather than seeking to advance a particular conception of what may make international law legitimate, this paper seeks to clarify and complicate how international lawyers understand and use legitimacy as a concept. Power is the central concept of the social sciences. Stillman 53 concept and the distinctions between legitimacy and other concepts.
Wps 1220 the concept of legitimacy and international law. For a government to rule successfully in a state, it must enjoy the full support and popular. The contemporary literature tends to judge this as too narrow, however. Because the realist project sought to use social science tools to examine human nature, the. Concepts of power, authority, legitimacy, responsibility. Though weber discussed it in the background of sociology the central idea remains more or less intact when it is applied in other disciplines, particularly political science. This paper examines the concepts of legitimacy and legitimation under nigerian laws with particular emphasis on case law. One recent attempt to define legitimacy has been made by carl j.
The problem of legitimacythe question of what makes a government legitimate or illegitimate and what justifies a certain type of. In this case, the system adapted to the wants of the citizens and the united states reestablished legitimacy. Pdf the concept of legitimacy peter stillman academia. Pdf the function of political institutions and the. This chapter discusses corporate social responsibility, corporate governance, and corporate citizenship in relation to business legitimacy as. Remarks at a workshop on legitimacy in international law held in june 2006 at the max planck institute for comparative public law and international law. Historically, legitimacy was associated with the state and institutions and decisions within the state. Many constitutional scholars offer their opinions about what the constitution means. In recent decades the term legitimacy has featured heavily in debates about international law and international institutions. The thesis builds a model of orthodox western legitimacy on the basis of the interaction of dominant paradigms in western thinking about the statessystem, the state and the international economy. This raises the question how the concept of legitimacy may applybeyond the nation state and decisions made within itto the international and global context. Legitimacy theory is derived from the concept of organisational legitimacy, which has been defined by dowling and pfeffer 1975, p. Of all the ideas central to socialist philosophy and practice, few have been scorned, misunderstood, celebrated or feared more than the idea of the dictatorship of the.
In view of the importance of the concept of legitimacy for political thought and action, an examination of the concept itself seems advisable. The concept of legitimacy in international relations. What is legitimacy and why does it matter for peace. One of the main reasons for a revision of the concept of public diplomacy is because it is being used by new actors. Since ancient time, social theorists tried to define the queries that people who lack economic power consent to hierarchies of social and political power. Therefore, legitimacy can be defined as the recognition and acceptance which the citizens give their leaders to rule them. Legitimacy, popular acceptance of a government, political regime, or system of governance. Pdf legitimacy is a key concept of any effort to theorize how governance works, contributing both to the effectiveness and to the normative.
Political acceptance as an alternative or complement to. Health care and the concept of legitimacy 425 traditional legitimacy develops through time as qualities of merit, valour and holiness become associ ated with a corporate group such as a lineage or sodality. Authority is a much more complex concept, and we need to make distinctions between several different ideas of authority. Investigating the role of legitimacy in the political order of conflicttorn spaces pdf. The word legitimacy can be interpreted in either a normative way or a positive see positivism way. Traditionally, public diplomacy was carried out specifically by the. If there is a formal constitutional basis, we can see legitimacy. Max weber and the concept of legitimacy in contemporary. The and effectiveness of non state actors and the public. Legitimacy definition is the quality or state of being legitimate. He seeks to use the strengths of traditional definitions which include reference to possession or pursuit of right values and modern social science notably carl friedrichs conceptions of legitimacy.
893 1072 139 758 1403 1328 1478 944 1047 389 575 991 1432 758 565 1001 718 478 1046 1217 1215 180 691 260 538 1239 361 220 1112 805 1302 862 558 558 1208 210 203 808